RROKA.com Forums - Make your voice heard!
Freedom of Speech

 
You must be logged in to post Forum Guidlines Current Concerns Business Directory
Search Forums:


 






Minimum search word length is 4 characters – Maximum search word length is 84 characters
Wildcard Usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

New monument up and running
Read original Report

UserPost

8:24 pm
October 29, 2011


Manager

Admin
Admin

posts 252

1

Monument looks quite impressive somewhere now for relatives to remember

 

 

 

 


Read original Report

9:51 pm
October 29, 2011


joshua

norwood

Member

posts 71

2

And can i say it looks fab!!!

jtbotham
yours in scouting

8:20 pm
November 11, 2011


Manager

Admin
Admin

posts 252

3

We have got a nice monument now and still we're having the rememberance at 2.30 in the afternoon this is a kick in the teeth for the fallen, if we cannot be bothered to turn up at the correct time, it allways looks like its a second thought and shows Killamarsh up. These soldiers need to be shown the great respect that they deserve for giving the ultimate sacrifice to keep us safe. I dont believe what people say we cannot get any band players so we have to have it late, everywhere else does it at the correct  time why not Killamarsh, we have had enough time to put it right but apathy prevails in this village.

Manyana manyana

8:46 pm
November 12, 2011


joshua

norwood

Member

posts 71

4

I see your point how ever the point of the march is importent not the time, i will be attending 2 marched one at 10 in clown and another at 2.30 in killamarsh, it will be a day that i will all ways remeber as the day we stop in killamarsh and come together to march for those we respect and love for giving there lives for us and i bet liam would be there at 2.30 with no compaint about the time. be strong Killamarsh, we not perfect but we are close :P

 

If anyone wants to say hi i'm the scout in a grey/brown shirt with a purple necker(i will be close to the scout section[ wearing green and blue]).

 

I will love to see everyone there at the march and the 40s style dinner event after.

 

YIS (Yours in scouting)

Joshua

jtbotham
yours in scouting

1:20 pm
November 13, 2011


whiskyman

Member

posts 87

5

Armistice does'nt say 2.30pm in Killamarsh we should get it correct for the Fallen show respect from the offset we are teaching the youth of today that it was a different time.

 

At 0530 hours on the 11th November 1918 Erzberger gave his consent to the conditions. Foch signed the document for the Allies and then Erzberger on behalf of the German Government. Signals were immediately sent out to the Allied commands:

The Armistice was to take effect at 11 o'clock, on the 11th day, of the 11th month.

Foch himself set out with the document for Paris

It was a cold wet and miserable day. At La Pierre d'Haudroy, Bugler Corporal Sellier who had first met the delegation a few days earlier and sounded a cease fire then, now sounded the end of the war to end all wars.

Half an hour later Erzberger and his delegation left the Forest of Compiègne on their way back to Tergnier where they were met by their own vehicles.

 

12:37 pm
November 16, 2011


Francis

Member

posts 91

6

I have attended every Killamarsh afternoon Remembrance Service with the band since 1971 – I have no idea why it is held in the afternoon and I would suggest that it may have been held in that format for even more years than the 40 years that I've been there.  The format has changed of those 40 years, the parade used to start outside the old cinema (now the doctors surgery) proceed to the church then halting by the old miners welfare on Kirkcroft Lane, opposite the Methodist Chapel (now a converted house) and on to the church. The parade would return the same route and finish at the side of the old Coop.

Perhaps you should speak to a member of the band to see if they can get there for your proposed time of 11am? Oh that would be me then.

However because the one at Killamarsh is held in the afternoon (as it is in many other villages) it means that the band members can attend other venues where they dont have a band.

I would suggest that the village was suitably honoured with the presence of both the local MP and the Lord Lieutenant of Derbyshire (as official representative of the Queen) – I know Natascha Engel was at Clay Cross in the morning as I was there too. I doubt if the service was held in the morning that these people would be there – would that show disrespect to the fallen?

 

To take Mr Manager's comments to its ultimate conclusion perhaps we should have the service on the 11th of the 11th and that as explained above is the relevant date? Being emotive and politically with the memory of dead soldiers is despicable.

 

Well done Joshua for your enlightened views and for your efforts in both the morning and afternoon.

12:46 pm
November 16, 2011


Francis

Member

posts 91

7

Post edited 1:07 pm – November 16, 2011 by Francis


As to teaching the children of today the correct time? I suggest that it should be compulsory for every school age child to visit the Menin Gate in Ypres, Belgium.  At 8pm every single day of the week the traffic passing under the memorial stops and single or a group of buglers sound the Last Post, they have every day since 1928. The only time this did not occur was during the occupation in the second world war, the bugles being hidden for this period. On the evening that Ypres was liberated, the bugles were brought out of hidding and sounded again.

Members of the band attended and played at a moving ceremony at the Menin Gate in August this year, laying a wreath and were honoured to be asked to play additional music after the evening service.

The ceremony is a solemn occasion, and therefore not intended as entertainment or a tourist attraction. The buglers usually remain at the scene for a short while after the ceremony, at which point appreciation can be expressed in person; it is not considered appropriate to applaud during, or after, the ceremony. The band received a spontanteous round of applause for its performance at the instigation of the principal organiser of the daily event.

 

The Menin Gate Memorial to the Missing is a war memorial in Ypres, Belgium dedicated to the commemoration of British and Commonwealth soldiers who were killed in the Ypres Salient of World War I and whose graves are unknown. The memorial is located at the eastern exit of the town and marks the starting point for one of the main roads out of the town that led Allied soldiers to the front line. Designed by Sir Reginald Blomfield and built by the British government, the Menin Gate Memorial was unveiled on 24 July 1927. It is inscribed with the names of 54,896 soldiers.

8:49 pm
November 16, 2011


Manager

Admin
Admin

posts 252

8

Post edited 8:59 pm – November 16, 2011 by Manager


Thanks for the info, I would like to add if it did'nt leave you with a lump in your throat at Menin gate your a hard man been twice and lump appeared everytime they do do it on time and it is very moving, suggest if you have not been, go to Hill 62 where the Canadians were holed up fighting the germans the photos of the wounded at the museum turns your heart into jelly and some of them fought on. Respect for these people is immense shame the worlds turned out like this. Hitler wanted to Bomb the Menin gate like he destroyed the train carriage which the Armistace was signed thank God he did'not succeed.

 

Some of the bloodiest fighting of World War One took place in the Flanders and Picardy regions of Belgium and Northern France. The poppy was the only thing which grew in the aftermath of the complete devastation. McCrae, a doctor serving there with the Canadian Armed Forces, deeply inspired and moved by what he saw, wrote these verses:

 

In Flanders' Fields
John McCrae, 1915

In Flanders' fields the poppies blow
Between the crosses, row on row,
That mark our place: and in the sky
The larks, still bravely singing, fly
Scarce heard amid the guns below.

We are the dead. Short days ago
We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,
Loved and were loved, and now we lie
In Flanders' fields.

Take up our quarrel with the foe;
To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high,
If ye break faith with us who die
We shall not sleep, though poppies grow
In Flanders' Fields.

On the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month in 1918, the First World War ended. Civilians wanted to remember the people who had given their lives for peace and freedom. An American War Secretary, Moina Michael, inspired by John McCrae's poem, began selling poppies to friends to raise money for the ex-Service community. And so the tradition began.

11:30 am
November 17, 2011


Francis

Member

posts 91

9

Manager said:

Thanks for the info, I would like to add if it did'nt leave you with a lump in your throat at Menin gate your a hard man been twice and lump appeared everytime they do do it on time and it is very moving..

 

I don't believe I said anything about not being moved by either the place or the ceremony. We also spent a morning at the Tyne Cot cemetery nearly 13,000 gravestones, and I defy anyone not to be moved by that.  That is why I suggested that this area of Belgium and Northern France should be visited by every school child in the country.

 

So we appear to be agreed on the significance of the place and the importance of its memory but please just accept the practicalities of when the event is held in Killamarsh. It is not a slur on anyone's memory that it takes place in the afteroon.

1:31 pm
November 17, 2011


Manager

Admin
Admin

posts 252

10

Its just a crying shame councils  cannot arrange to do a ceremony at the correct time, could not see the march past the Cenotaph going down very well at 2.30pm there would be an outcry those that do it in the afternoon should be ashamed the excuses are very lame  each individual council should be able to arrange a bugler and a march past at the correct time its seems like an after thought its like turning up late for a wedding its all over. The two mins silence is at 11am not 2.30 the uniterested attitude shows us up.

2:12 pm
November 18, 2011


Francis

Member

posts 91

11

Do you just post stuff on here to wind people up, because you are doing a good job at it.  Yes its a shame it doesn't happen at 11am on either the 11th or the nearest Sunday – however in Killamarsh its been that way for more than two generations.  Perhaps you might like to find out why it was held in the afternoon? 

 

For many years the event was organised by The Royal British Legion and attendance became less and less it is only since the Afghan conflict that numbers have increased. The Legion gave up the organising and handed it on to the Parish Council about 10 years ago.

 

I have no idea why you consider that the people who turned up in the afternoon (many of whom also where in attendance somewhere else in the morning) should feel ashamed?I didn't and I doubt anyone else did, perhaps you were the only one standing there thinking I wish this had been at 11am.  The service was held with all the due reverence and the silence was observed.  Some of the village gave their respects and the dead were honoured.

11:09 pm
November 24, 2011


joshua

norwood

Member

posts 71

12

can i say Francis you are a legend, as i say you do a wonderfull job giving us info, but this topic is silly as i said before its no the time its the respect we pay, you are amazing Francis.

YIS

Joshua

jtbotham
yours in scouting

11:48 pm
November 24, 2011


whiskyman

Member

posts 87

13

 If I remember it was the old silver band that had the time changed quite a number of years ago something about the marching and playing I think, will have to ask around. As to the time it should now be put back to the correct time as you dont turn up at 2.30 for an 11.00 o clock appointment its all over.Confused

1:53 pm
November 25, 2011


Francis

Member

posts 91

14

Can I again state that the timing of the Remembrance Parade in Killamarsh has nothing to do with the band.  I thought I'd answered the first specualtion on this, clearly 40 years attendance isn't enough of a time span.  I have spoken to a retired member of the band who first attended the Remembrance in Killamarsh in 1952 (nearly 60 years ago and 3 generations worth of family members involved with the band since).

He states that it has always been in the afternoon.

As to Mr Whiskeyman's comment about marching and playing, well the band have not taken part in the parade for many years – at the time due to the age of the player.  But the timing of the parade was never changed because of this.

Lots of things have changed in the 60 years that our retired member took part, route of the parade, the inclusion of the Beighton Scout band and the Eckington Air Cadets (both whom presummably attend their own village parades in the morning).Many years ago the parade would quick march as far as Kikrcroft Lane where they would meet up with the Church Choir and then slow march to the church.The addition of the 40s Tea party for those attending as a thankyou from the parish

 

The one constant seems to have been the afternoon timing…. unless someone knows different?

 

 

2:59 pm
November 27, 2011


joshua

norwood

Member

posts 71

15

Sorry but random thing, the march i have been told did start at the old cinema (Doctors surgery to me and you) and then the march as you said. am i right or wrong ?

 

YIS

Joshua

jtbotham
yours in scouting

11:18 pm
November 29, 2011


Francis

Member

posts 91

16

joshua said:

Sorry but random thing, the march i have been told did start at the old cinema (Doctors surgery to me and you) and then the march as you said. am i right or wrong ?

 

YIS

Joshua

That is correct, it did indeed start there. I mentioned in an early post.

1:26 pm
November 30, 2011


joshua

norwood

Member

posts 71

17

Ty im talking to my grandad and he said it started at the cineama and i didnt know where it was but you just clearified my point. Thanks Franis u rock, Rest of you 2.30 is fine in fact better for me so i can do more then one march now leave it alone, if you get the time changed i will have no happyness in the event thats what makes us special. Killamarsh ROCKS and no one can change that.

 

YIS

Joshua

jtbotham
yours in scouting



About the RROKA.com Forum

Forum Timezone: UTC 1

Most Users Ever Online: 28

Currently Online:
6 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3
Forums: 16
Topics: 134
Posts: 691

Membership:

There are 70 Members

There are 2 Admins
There is 1 Moderator

Top Posters:

SipsiCymreig – 122
Francis – 91
whiskyman – 87
joshua – 71
ROOSTER – 39
Matty – 24

Recent New Members: Captain Memo, embersNeive

Administrators: Web Developer (46 Posts), Manager (252 Posts)

Moderators: Web Developer (46 Posts)